Case Study · Teaching Fellowship

1,000+ applicants from paid channels for a selective teaching fellowship.

1,000+ applicants from paid channels for a selective teaching fellowship.

1,000+ applicants from paid channels for a selective teaching fellowship.

A six-month recruitment campaign that hit the applicant target and opened a younger audience the program had not reached before.

A six-month recruitment campaign that hit the applicant target and opened a younger audience the program had not reached before.

Target

1,000+

completed applications

Target

1,000+

completed applications

Target

1,000+

completed applications

Channels

Google + Meta

roughly $30–$33 per applicant

Channels

Google + Meta

roughly $30–$33 per applicant

Unlocked

A younger audience

through a message no one had tested

Unlocked

A younger audience

through a message no one had tested

The challenge wasn’t demand. It was selectivity.

The challenge wasn’t demand. It was selectivity.

The challenge wasn’t demand. It was selectivity.

The fellowship only works if it can choose a small cohort from a large pool of strong candidates. Each cohort takes around 120 fellows out of thousands of applicants. That means the top of the funnel has to stay big enough and strong enough for selectivity to mean anything.

The fellowship only works if it can choose a small cohort from a large pool of strong candidates. Each cohort takes around 120 fellows out of thousands of applicants. That means the top of the funnel has to stay big enough and strong enough for selectivity to mean anything.

The younger audience needed a different answer.

The younger audience needed a different answer.

The younger audience needed a different answer.

The proven messages worked for career changers. They didn’t work for younger candidates. Interviews surfaced the real barrier: teaching read as outdated. So the next campaign dropped nostalgia and led with the most innovative parts of the training itself.

What already worked

Meaningful work. A teacher who shaped you.

Strong for mid-career changers. Not enough for younger skeptics.

What already worked

Meaningful work. A teacher who shaped you.

Strong for mid-career changers. Not enough for younger skeptics.

What unlocked the audience

Same program, different front door.

Lead with the innovation in the training, not nostalgia for teaching.

What unlocked the audience

Same program, different front door.

Lead with the innovation in the training, not nostalgia for teaching.

Every ad had a job.

Every ad had a job.

Every ad had a job.

This wasn’t one campaign with rotating ads. We mapped distinct personas, placed each on the awareness ladder, and shifted the messaging with the recruitment timeline: awareness early, consideration in the middle, action as deadlines approached.

This wasn’t one campaign with rotating ads. We mapped distinct personas, placed each on the awareness ladder, and shifted the messaging with the recruitment timeline: awareness early, consideration in the middle, action as deadlines approached.

Campaign rhythm

Awareness

early

Consideration

middle

Action

deadline

Person → stage → next step.

Campaign rhythm

Awareness

early

Consideration

middle

Action

deadline

Person → stage → next step.

The campaign hit the target — and changed the audience.

The campaign hit the target — and changed the audience.

The campaign hit the target — and changed the audience.

Over 1,000 completed applications from paid Google and Meta. Not “leave your details” leads — real applications to a program most applicants knew they probably wouldn’t get into. The younger audience came in through a message no one had tested until we asked the fellows themselves.

Over 1,000 completed applications from paid Google and Meta. Not “leave your details” leads — real applications to a program most applicants knew they probably wouldn’t get into. The younger audience came in through a message no one had tested until we asked the fellows themselves.

Outcome

1,000+ completed applicants

including an audience the client had never reached before

Outcome

1,000+ completed applicants

including an audience the client had never reached before

The problem behind the program

The teacher shortage doesn’t hit every school equally.

The teacher shortage doesn’t hit every school equally.

The teacher shortage doesn’t hit every school equally.

UNESCO estimates the world will need 44 million more teachers by 2030. The shortage consistently hits rural and disadvantaged areas hardest — where students most need strong teachers, and are least likely to get them.

UNESCO estimates the world will need 44 million more teachers by 2030. The shortage consistently hits rural and disadvantaged areas hardest — where students most need strong teachers, and are least likely to get them.

Global shortage

44M

teachers needed by 2030

Rural and disadvantaged schools feel it first.

Global shortage

44M

teachers needed by 2030

Rural and disadvantaged schools feel it first.

Global shortage

44M

teachers needed by 2030

Rural and disadvantaged schools feel it first.

  • Fellowships · Bootcamps · Courses · Newsletters · Career programs · Research programs · Training cohorts · Communities · Fieldbuilding

  • Fellowships · Bootcamps · Courses · Newsletters · Career programs · Research programs · Training cohorts · Communities · Fieldbuilding

ANNA PITNER · MARKETING · ANNA PITNER · MARKETING · ANNA PITNER · MARKETING · ANNA PITNER · MARKETING · ANNA PITNER · MARKETING · ANNA PITNER · MARKETING · ANNA PITNER · MARKETING · AP

© 2026 Anna Pitner Marketing, LLC. Built for high-impact programs.

Copy & design by yours truly